
7. 42- Director Graeme Harper, the same man who gave us so many classics, such as; the best regeneration story to date, 1984’s ‘The Caves of Androzani’ and the best 80’s Dalek story, ‘Revelation of the Daleks,’ the two-part Cybermen story of 2005, ‘Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel’ and that year’s explosive finale, ‘Doomsday’… returns to work on a gimmicky and so-so story.
There’s no justice, is there?
The Doctor and Martha land on a spacecraft that is plummeting towards a sun. The story is hampered with the ‘real time’ gimmick that our heroes must solve the problem witin the 42 minutes of the program’s run time (I have no idea how this will play out when it gets edited for US transmission). Throw into this frantic pace the charismatic crew that have so little time to register that I’m still struggling to figure out what program so-and-so is from by the time he or she is killed or drenched in red light and sweat.
Martha is hurled into a sub-plot as she and a nameless sweaty technician attempt to hack their way through a series of doors protected by questions programmed by the crew during an all-night drink-up. While it’s not a bad concept, it plays out as an embarrassing conceit that works against the program’s futuristic setting (why would they care about who had more #1’s out of the Beatles and Elvis?). It’s such a lame idea that even the Doctor can’t be bothered and Martha has to phone her mum who is still trying to talk her out of traveling with the Doctor because of info fed to her by the evil camp of PM-hopeful Mr. Saxon.
Add to this pacey runaround a possessed crewman who is killing off the crew by raising his visor and saying ‘Burn with me’ and you’ve got one of the most contrived Doctor Who stories to date.
It’s like the production team thought ‘we need to introduce a moody villain with a catchphrase in every other story.’ It ends up making the program seem far sillier and less imaginative than it needs to be.
The phrase ‘burn with me’ is hardly even a clue to the solution of the problem, it’s just an evil phrase. The possessed men might have instead saaid ‘Oooga-booga’ with about as much meaning.
All of this aside, it does look wonderful. The CGI ship, the sun and the possessed ‘effect’ are all great visuals. The acting is top notch and the cinematography is outstanding. The set is almost identical to last year’s ‘Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit’ which reduces the program’s already slim margin of impact. In fact, I had to remind myself what happened in this story before writing the review.
Martha spends some time trapped in a life pod with some nameless very polite guy and decides to call her mum which seems very odd considering both of them are very… up for it. This continues the ‘Martha loves the Doctor‘ storyline and throws a few extra minutes into the ‘Mr. Saxon’ storyline which is clever but perhaps not as well told as it should be.
I feel there should be a little inset image of John Simm in the bottom of the screen every time Saxon gets mentioned. The Saxon threat is so disembodied, that it’s difficult to pay attention to it.
The Doctor goes through perhaps his most harrowing experience as he is possessed and almost driven to tears with fear that he’ll hurt the crew. It’s a character defining moment that Tennant pulls off with aplomb. The conclusion involves lots of shouting and a button push to release the sentient energy that the ship scooped up and the trouble is over.
Not the most memorable episode, 42 did have lots of style and character. I still say that Harper saved a lame script, but at least the conclusion did not involve the Doctor waltzing in front of the villain and pressing a button to end the threat.
Read the rest of this entry »
Escaping a mundane and pedestrian lifestyle is the true intent of any fan of sci-fi. We don’t just want to read about it, we yearn to live the adventure.
Not as flashy as your own stylishly cut space suit and a raygun that gos ‘Wuuu wuu wuu’ to fight aliens with but it makes sense.
